Reviews
Part of How to plan, run and measure a business internship properly
Must a business internship be paid? The FLSA test explained
Whether a business internship must pay turns on the FLSA primary beneficiary test and its seven factors. How to read an offer and count the real cost.
Whether an internship pays is a legal question in the United States, not one of generosity. A defined test decides it, and the test turns on who primarily benefits from the arrangement.
That framing is more useful than any figure, because it shows what to check in a program before you commit a summer to it.
This page sets out the rule under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) that decides whether a business internship must be paid at all, the seven factors behind it, and the parts of a package that are easy to miss.
What to take away
- Whether an unpaid internship is lawful turns on a test about who primarily benefits, not on whether both sides agreed to it.
- A stipend, a travel allowance and a housing contribution are three different things and only one of them is usually treated as wages.
- The real cost of an internship is what you spend to take it, and that is where a paid and an unpaid offer diverge most.
The test that decides it
The US Department of Labor applies a primary beneficiary analysis to interns at for-profit employers. Its Wage and Hour Division set it out in Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2018-2, which rescinded the April 2010 version of Fact Sheet No. 71 and its earlier six-part test. The bulletin lists the seven factors courts have considered:
- How clearly the intern and the employer understand that there is no expectation of compensation.
- How far the internship provides training similar to what an educational environment would give.
- How far it is tied to the intern's formal education program by integrated coursework or academic credit.
- How far it accommodates the intern's academic commitments by following the academic calendar.
- Whether its duration is limited to the period in which it provides beneficial learning.
- Whether the intern's work complements, rather than displaces, the work of paid employees.
- Whether both sides understand there is no entitlement to a paid job at the end.
Primary beneficiary factors
- What each side understood about payment
- Tied to formal education
- Accommodates academic commitments
- Limited to learning period
- Intern does not displace paid staff
Two things about that test are commonly misunderstood. It is not a checklist where a majority wins; the factors are weighed together against the facts. And an agreement to work unpaid does not settle it, because the question is what the arrangement is, not what it was called.
Different rules apply to public sector and non-profit placements: the bulletin notes that unpaid internships for public sector and non-profit charitable organizations, where the intern volunteers without expectation of compensation, are generally permissible. Other countries have their own arrangements entirely. Check the rule for the jurisdiction you are actually in.
Reading an internship offer
- Is the payment described as wages, as a stipend, or as a reimbursement? Each is treated differently and only the first is straightforwardly pay.
- Are the hours defined, and what happens if the team works longer ones? The overtime requirements apply to a paid intern who is not exempt, the same as to anyone else.
- Is anything conditional on completing the full term? A payment held to the end is a retention device, and it should be read as one.
- Are travel, equipment or accommodation provided, reimbursed, or yours?
- Is there academic credit, and does your institution charge tuition for it? Credit is not free, and in some arrangements it is the largest single cost.
The cost side, which is where the decision usually turns
An internship's value to you is what you learn and what it converts into. Its price is what you spend to be there. For a placement away from home, the housing and travel are frequently larger than any stipend, which means an offer with a small payment can cost more than an unpaid one nearby.
Costs to count
Cost
- Housing
- Provided, subsidized or yours?
- Travel
- Once or weekly, reimbursed?
- Equipment
- Supplied or your expense?
- Academic credit
- Institution charges tuition?
- Foregone earnings
- Alternative summer pay?
Question before accepting
- Housing
- Travel
- Equipment
- Academic credit
- Foregone earnings
The cost side
| Cost to count | Question to ask before accepting |
|---|---|
| Housing for the term | Is it provided, subsidized, or entirely yours? |
| Travel to and from | Once, or weekly, and reimbursed at what rate? |
| Equipment and clothing | Supplied, or an expense you carry? |
| Academic credit | Does your institution charge for the credit hours? |
| Foregone earnings | What would the alternative summer have paid? |
The last row is the one students leave out and it is usually the biggest. An unpaid placement with a strong conversion record can still be the better decision; the point is to make it knowing what it costs rather than discovering it in October.
What the money does not tell you
A well-paid internship at an employer with no plan is worth less than a modest one with a defined project, a named supervisor and a real handover at the end.
What money does not tell you
- Defined project you own
- Named supervisor who reviews
- Real handover at the end
- Work legible to an outsider
- What last cohort did afterward
What determines the term's worth afterward is structural. The internships guide covers the same points: whether you own something, whether anyone reviews it, and whether the work is legible to somebody who was not there.
Ask what the last cohort did afterward. Skip the conversion rate, which nobody outside the employer can verify. Ask what previous interns were given to do and where they went. An employer that cannot answer has not thought about it.
The same question decides whether a permanent role has a future. That is why it recurs throughout the guide to salaries and advancement.
Where an official figure would come from
For a baseline on what the underlying job pays, go to the national statistics body and read its definitions first. Placements and traineeships are largely invisible in occupational wage data because they are short, part-year and often unpaid, so the right approach is to look up the occupation the internship sits inside rather than the internship itself.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics explains what its wage estimates cover on the questions and answers page of its Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) program, which produces employment and wage estimates for approximately 830 occupations. That scope note is the part to read before using any of its figures.
An apprenticeship is the other structured route into paid work. It is built differently, with pay from the start and defined progression.
In the United States that route is Registered Apprenticeship, overseen by the Department of Labor's Office of Apprenticeship through the National Registered Apprenticeship System. Its guidance for people looking for one is worth reading beside any internship offer, because the comparison clarifies what you are actually being offered. Where either route leads afterward is a separate question, and the guide to searching for work covers the mechanics of the move.
Common questions
Can I agree to work unpaid if I want the experience?
Your agreement is one factor among several and it does not settle the question. If the arrangement is primarily for the employer's benefit, the law may treat you as an employee whatever both sides intended.
Is a stipend the same as a wage?
Not necessarily. A stipend may be a fixed sum unrelated to hours, which is exactly why employers use the word. Ask whether it is being treated as wages, because the answer affects taxes and everything downstream of them.
Should I take an unpaid placement at a well-known employer over a paid one at a small firm?
Only after counting the cost of the unpaid one and asking both employers what you would actually own. A name is worth something on a resume and it is worth nothing if the term produced no work you can describe. How to describe it afterward is the subject of the resumes and cover letters guide.
What if the internship turns into doing the job of someone who left?
Then the arrangement has changed, and it is reasonable to say so and ask for it to be put on a proper footing. Displacing a paid worker is one of the factors that counts against an unpaid arrangement.
Do these rules apply outside the United States?
No. The structure of the question is similar in many places and the specific test is not. Find the equivalent guidance from the labor authority where the placement is, and read it before you sign anything.
